Review: Clannad
Story: 6.5
When I heard there was going to be another anime by the same makers a Kanon2006, I knew I wanted to watch this. And even though I think the story from Kanon was better, I wasn’t disappointed by this series, far from. Like Kanon, this series is build up in different arcs that focus on one character. Tomoya is the male lead and there are several female students in his surroundings who he somehow manages to become friends with. As he gets involved in their lives, he comes across as really helpful to aid these girls whenever he can. Each of these girls has their problems or insecurities to face and Tomoya lends a helping hand. The main story line which ties all the characters together is about Nagisa whose dream is to re-start the drama club at their school. There isn’t really going on much plot wise in this series since it is mostly the character development that makes this series interesting. It is a pity though that some characters didn’t get as much screen time as others and it left me wondering what could have been their motives.
I am personally a huge fan of the animation style used in this series. I really like the big eyed girls and their hairdos. Because of the detailed backgrounds and the vivid colors this anime was a joy for the eye. I feel there isn’t much more to say about this point since I can’t really find anything bad about it.
From all the songs of this series I like the one that closes up Fuuko’s arc the best, but the opening theme is also very beautiful. The rest of the soundtrack delivers a good quality of songs which I actually enjoy listen to on its own. The Dango theme sounds like a lullaby which is interwoven with the whole series. The voice actors also do excellent jobs on personalizing the characters and like the animation I really have nothing to complain about here.
As stated before this series involves around Tomoya who does anything for others as long as he doesn’t have to go home. I really like his sarcastic character and I think it is one of the best male leads I have seen in a series. As with all Key adaptations, Clannad has a huge side cast. There are several girls that get in touch with Tomoya somehow. I do feel that there are a bit too many characters in Clannad because as mentioned before some characters didn’t get the screen time they deserved. However the characters that did are likable characters with interesting tales to follow.
I would defiantly recommend it to anyone who liked the other Key adaptations. This one is more realistic then Kanon and Air however it still has the same quality and charm. I found it a good watch even though some things remain unexplained in the end.
Zero no Tsukaima
Story: 7,5
In a fictional fantasy world the power of magic is held in high respect, and those who can use it are considered the nobility of that world, where those without the ability to use magic are treated as inferior in every aspect: not quite slavery just yet, but definitely a difference in class. Louise is one of these nobles, however also one of the worst, and pretty much every attempt at using advanced magic ends in failure or destruction.
The first episode introduces this new world, at an important day at the academy of magic: the day when each student summons his or her familiar, a magical creature destined to accompany them. All sorts of strange and wonderful creatures are summoned, but Louise’s familiar is something else altogether: a young boy from our present-day
Even though he’s from another world, most others simply see him as a commoner, someone who can’t use magic, ridiculing him, and frustrating Louise even further –another failure-, frustration which she violently takes out on Saito.
At first there doesn’t seem to be much going on Zero No Tsukaima, a chain of loose episodes, but gradually a storyline starts to develop, though it rushes with some plot twists around halfway, introducing a lot of new elements. But everything ties together in the end, even though some aspects of the story still feel a bit rushed to me…
Graphics: 7
Graphically, Zero no Tsukaima is nothing to write home about, though the animation is far from bad either. There are some stills, but nothing which disrupts the flow of the series, and the action sequences are good. Nothing to write home about, but nothing bad either.
Audio: 7,5
The same as with graphics, season 1 of Zero was good, it set the mood well, but apart from a few strong tracks, it wasn’t really something to write home about. Average. The voice acting was well though, enthusiastic and professional, no complaints there.
Characters: 7
The series introduces a set of fairly cliché characters early on: the silent brainiac with glasses, the rose-wielding arrogant but cowardly playboy, the busty attention-craving female, etcetera. Fortunately there’s room for some more original characters as well, such as a talking sword, or the headmaster, who looks like he could’ve been swept straight from a Harry Potter movie, except for his pervy nature to use his pet mouse to find out the color of girls’ underwear.
The relationship between Louise and Saito is pretty much defined from the start: she is the noble, and he is a commoner and a familiar, a lowly servant without any real rights. But Zero no Tsukaima has a romantic element as well, so of course more is bound to happen… were it not for complicated love triangles and at least a handful of others having an interest in poor Saito, while Louise in turn keeps denying her feelings.
However just as important as a good hero is a good villain, and since the story feels a bit rushed sometimes (perhaps 12 episodes is too little?) most of the villains aren’t really developed as well; in fact, most of them are only introduced in the last few episodes, which in turn gives them very little depth.
Overall: 7
Zero No Tsukaima is a fun little series and has all the potential of becoming a popular series: a fairly original setting, good characters, a promising plot –which I can’t tell much about since some vital elements are only introduced in the final episodes- and a nice mixture of action and comedy. Season II is out, and if it improves a bit in the story department, it could be a hit indeed.
Gakuen Alice Review
Story: 7
Gakuen Alice is presented as a comedy and while this anime certainly has comical elements, it didn’t make me laugh out loud much. This doesn’t mean this is a bad anime; it just wasn’t what I expected. I was pleasantly surprised when I noticed the deeper elements that this story had to offer. On the surface it seems like any ordinary school life anime, but as the story progresses you get drawn deeper and deeper in the underlying secrets of this school. Hidden motives are a keyword in this series and it was interesting enough for me to finish this one in 2 days.
The animation is pretty basic, yet they spend time to add details to the total picture. This is especially clear in the character designs. They made certain that the animation fitted with the unique characters of certain personalities. Also it is one of those series where characters actually wear different every day clothes instead of the same thing over and over, of course the school uniform is the exception here.
The comedy aspects are brought out more by using exaggerated facial expressions. To my opinion this really adds something extra to the series.
Voice acting is good overall. Most of the times the voices fit the characters however there is one boy though who sounds like a girl and I think it took me about 4 episodes before I noticed he was a boy because of his uniform.
The opening theme is a wacky song that fits the anime well. The ending theme is a mellow song, almost like a lullaby. Both songs aren’t bad, but I wouldn’t play them on their own. It is too bad that the former are the only two vocal tracks for a 26 episode series. The scenes in the series are accompanied by little weird sounds to accent the comedy aspect. As for background music, they use the same tunes over and over but this is only noticeable if you pay attention to it.
When Mikan, the main character first comes to the new school, almost everyone acts cold towards here. But with her personality she wins people over 1 by 1. This is the main event for this series and if you compare the beginning of the series to the end there is a major difference. They did a good job here, following this line of development. Mikan stays the same cheerful girl overall in spite of all the hardships she has to endure, yet she still develops to a stronger person. Even if she still stays a crybaby in the end.
To my opinion a lot of people will be able to enjoy this series. Some will appreciate it for the humor while others might be drawn to the drama aspects of the anime. There is also some action involved and is has a deeper story then expected. The ending could have been stronger and it is true that the series leaves quite a few things untold. All though these flaws are there, I nevertheless enjoyed watching it.
Karin review
Story: 7
I normally dislike vampire stories. Sure, I don’t have a problem with a series that happen to have a vampire in it, however I wouldn’t normally watch an anime where it all involves around these creatures of the night. Yet, when I read the synopsis of this series, I got curious and decided to watch it.
I normally dislike anime that has blood. However if there is blood it is animated in an almost cute way. For example flower shaped blood. Even though it is unrealistic, I really liked it because in this way I can handle blood.
Further the animation is nothing really special; it is the kind you normally encounter in a romance anime. Backgrounds aren’t really detailed, but characters have more details and most were aimed to look cute. Some characters look slightly odd but there is always a reason behind it. Extra details were laid in the different costumes characters wear. A thing that did draw extra attention was the last episode which was fully drawn in a grey and red palette.
The first thing that stands out is the classical vampire sounds that are used as a comical note in this anime. I find this very well done and it made me laugh on several occasions. The voice acting is done splendid. Karin’s father Henry has this really amusing voice and Winners voice has a bad American accent which fit his character well. All other voices are also fitting so the series scores high marks here. The opening theme is a catchy upbeat song. The ending song is somewhat mellower. Both aren’t outstanding however I have heard far worse.
There are a lot of characters in Karin. At first it starts out with her, most of her family, best friend and Usui Kenta, the male lead of the anime. First the anime focuses of Karins daily life and how she gets along with this unusual situations she gets involved in and Usui Kenta who discovers Karin’s secret. It shows the weird family structure and their way of caring for Karin.
This anime made me warm up towards vampires, and I enjoyed watching it. Even though there are some points of annoyance as well. It isn’t the most outstanding anime out there but if you want to see something lighthearted about vampires then this is a good pick, even if you normally aren’t into the vampire genre much, I would still recommend you try it out.
Tsubasa Chronicle : The movie (Princess of the Birdcage Kingdom)
Story: 7,5
The CLAMP studio has already been around for quite a while and produced a good variety of different mangas and, additionally, anime shows, most of which became little gems of their own. An item which has been seen several times before in CLAMP shows has been the re-use of characters: some characters can make a new appearance in a different series, either as the same character or as a completely different personality who has nothing in common with the original, except for appearance.
The Tsubasa Chronicle series takes that aspect one step further, by re-using every CLAMP character in existence, several times over: the series is based on the concept of the existence of many different world in different realities, each with their own theme. The same people can exist in different worlds, and yet while they may look the same, their characters might be as opposite as day and night.
The plot of the Tsubasa Chronicle in a nutshell: the princess Sakura (originally from Card Captor Sakura) is lured into ancient ruins and loses all her memories as a result, which are scattered across different worlds and dimensions. Determined to win them back, thus saving her life, her childhood friend and potential lover Saiyoran journeys with her to the Dimensional Witch because it’s believed she can help him. She gives him the ability to travel between worlds (in the form of the cute creature Mokona), but in exchange Sakura will never be able to remember their past together. Saiyoran agrees and sets off on this journey, together with two others, Fai and Kurogane, both who have their own reasons to travel across worlds.
After a whole season of traveling, finding feathers, and bonding between main characters, the movie is a logical continuation of that; in reality, the Tsubasa movie is little more than a lengthy, drawn out episode, and that’s also its main flaw: there’s a story to be told, and in this case that story would take more than one episode, yet at the same time the movie is short, and trying to cram as much of that story into as little time as possible. The result is that some things aren’t explained that well, or rushed through, and it may leave the viewer confused sometimes.
Graphics: 8,5
After seeing the first season of Tsubasa Chronicle, this ‘movie’ came as a bit of a surprise. A different studio was responsible for this production, and it was notable in a subtle change of animation and redesign of characters, both in outfit and appearance. Fortunately, none of this seems to disrupt the flow of the movie in any way, apart from taking a moment to get used to.
However the movie is fast paced, leaving no room for filler scenes or long (boring) dialogues, mixing said dialogues with camera changes, rather than using a lot of stills. There’s plenty of action, yet it isn’t all about action, and this movie creates a fine balance of that.
Audio: 8,5
A good soundtrack can either make or break an anime series, and where Tsubasa Chronicle is concerned the soundtrack serves only to strengthen the anime, with soft calm tones during quieter scenes, romantic melody where romance is required, and wild, upbeat orchestral tracks to intensify the action scenes. The only real shame is that, though the Tsubasa movie introduces some new tracks, some of the old ones are also re-used, even after a whole season of it all.
Characters: 8
With every new episode (or in this case, a “movie”) it’s always a surprise what kind of characters will be introduced; of course there are the main characters, who travel between worlds, along with both good guys (the Dimensional Witch) and bad guys (Fei Wong Reed) who watch and influence them from the sideline, but in every world characters from different series and previous worlds are re-used and it’s always a matter of finding out whether or not they are good, bad, have hidden agendas, dark pasts, etc.
This ‘movie’ brings back some old characters in new roles –or similar roles, since Tomoya has been a princess in several worlds already- but also introduces some new faces, which are a welcome sight.
There isn’t much room for character development since most characters are too busy rushing back and forth either carrying out evil schemes or preventing them, but there is a glimpse of the love relationship which is about to blossom (again) between Saiyoran and Sakura, though this movie by itself does not indulge further into it, leaving that story to be told another time.
Overall: 8
As I already mentioned, the title “movie” isn’t totally fitting of this Tsubasa Chronicle installement, and while it does influence the overall quality of this title a bit, it’s still a worthwhile movie to watch. It’s still recommended you watch season 1 of the series first though, since pretty much everything in this movie has references back to it, and you won’t have much of a clue about what’s going on if you don’t. But Tsubasa fans will agree that it’s a good… episode.
Lovely Complex Review
Story: 7
The concept of this anime is simple: You have a girl who is 1.70 tall and a guy who is 1.56 short with loud characters, who both face certain problems due to their heights, throw in an entertaining side cast and you have Lovely Complex. The first part of the anime is immense funny because both main characters dislike each other and constantly tease one another with their lengths.
I would describe the animation as simple and sometimes plain ugly. This is done intentionally to bring out the comedy aspect more. For example: Risa is drawn in a way that she seems even longer then she already is. Everything in the anime is drawn kind of exaggerated, like for instance facial expressions. I really liked this aspect of the animation, especially because the characters also react to the ugly drawn facial expressions. It might take some time to get used to the style but I grew to like it, it really supports the absurdness of this anime.
The voice acting of the series is brilliantly done! The actors manage to bring out the comedy even more. Also the voices from the side cast fitted the characters well.
The first opening theme is catchy; however to my opinion the singer isn’t the best out there and the second opening is even worse. The first ending is a slow, mellow song but it didn’t catch my attention to ever finish it once throughout the whole series. I had to listen to it just now so I was able to write something about it; however it is the best song of the series. The accompanying background music and sound effects are once again to support the comedy aspect of the series and they succeed at doing so.
This is the main focus of the series since the plot itself isn’t very thick. The relationship between the main characters undergoes several stages throughout the series. Also the main characters separately grow throughout the series, especially Risa, the female lead. I have to say all though I admire her for her determination; she also became a very whiny character and cries almost every episode. It certainly became a point of annoyance at points.
Even though I think this series would have been better if it would have been 12 episodes, I generally enjoyed watching it. The absurd comedy effects in animations and characters made this anime one of the better comedies out there, especially the first half of the series is really good. I wouldn’t watch it though if you are not into the romance theme, because the focus is more shifted to that aspect in the second part of the series. Even though the comedy aspects remain, the whiny factor can become a point of annoyance.
Still with these flaws I had a good time watching it and I think a lot of people will be able to appreciate the absurd outlook on romance that this series offers.