Manga: Sunadokei (The sand Chronicles) vol. 1

Sunadokei vol 1

Warning: This document contains spoilers

Story: 7
Sunadokei (hourglass) is about a girl, Ann, who remembers the life she leads when she was younger. She came to live in a remote village with her grandparents and has to make new friends there. She has some hard times but she manages. There is a chapter when she is 12 years old and a chapter when she is 14 years old. A friendship starts between her and Daigo, the male lead. When Daigo helps Ann through some rough times, Ann, realizes she loves Daigo. The main focus is on the relationship between Ann and Daigo, however there is also Fuji who likes Ann too. And there the classical love triangle is born. However for a Shojo romance it has a deep dramatic story behind the surface.

Art: 5.5
The art is like any typical Shojo manga, cute with some sparkles here and there to enchant things. While eyes are the stronger point of this mangaka (all though even sometimes the eyes are a bit off) mouths seem to be her weak point. Sometimes moths are drawn just plain ugly, too big or too thick lined. Sometimes body proportions are kinda off as well. It is not really the best drawing I have seen.

Character development: 6
As stated before part one of the manga focuses mainly on the relationship between Ann and Daigo. You see how they become friends, and slowly develop into more. There is the regular turning and twisting and the female rival also comes along.

In addition there are some scenes between Ann and Fuji where you can see clearly the one-sided love from him towards Ann. You see how he is hurt by it since he also knows Ann loves Daigo.

The characters themselves don’t seem to grow that much yet, except from the innocent youth to puberty and things get a bit awkward.. All though some events happen to keep the story going, I didn’t notice much change between the 12 year old characters and the 14 year old ones. But it might be that is for later in the other volumes.

Overall: 6
I don’t dislike this manga, it is kind of interesting and endearing, yet the far from perfect artwork throws me out of it. It prevents me from really getting into the story, I keep thinking: “Hmm.. that angle is off or that mouth is so unnatural.” It really meddled with my reading pleasure therefore I do not know if I will be reading all of this manga. I might give it another volume but the story must make up then what the art lacks, or the art must have improved by then. All in all I think this is just a manga for true Shojo fans.

No Comments »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

March 8, 2008 :: Drama, Manga, Romance, Shojo ::